Hard National Security Choices
Support Thursday, June 8, 2023
Menu

Case Documents

Take Me Back to the FOB Blog Home Page

The Oversight Board uses a docket number system somewhat akin to that used in U.S. federal courts. The docket numbers reveal the year the Oversight Board accepted the case, the number ordinal number of the case, the platform that the content in question appeared on (Facebook ("FB") or Instagram ("IG")) and whether the case reached the board by way of a user appeal ("UA") or a direct referral from Facebook ("FBR").

Below are brief descriptions of the cases and links to relevant documents, all organized chronologically by docket number. You can also sort by decided or pending cases by clicking the buttons below, or search for specific keywords to find relevant cases.

Decided Cases Pending Cases
 
 
 

Policy Advisory Opinions

PAO 2023-01 ("Shaheed" and Designated Dangerous Individuals) 

  • This policy advisory opinion request concerns Meta's approach to moderating the Arabic term "shaheed," when used to refer to individuals it classifies as dangerous. The word has multiple meanings but is often translated as "martyr" and accounts for more content removals under the Community Standards than any other single word on Meta's platforms, specifically, the company's Dangerous Individuals and Organizations policy.
  • Meta request for policy advisory opinion (2/8/23)
  • Oversight Board description (3/9/23)

2021-001 PAO (Sharing of Residential Information)

2021-002-FB-PAO (Meta's Cross-Check Policies)

  • This policy advisory opinion concerns Meta's cross-check system. Meta referred it to the board, requesting guidance on how to ensure fairness of cross-check reviews, who is included, and how to govern and promote transparency of the policies.
  • Meta request for policy advisory opinion (9/28/2021)
  • Oversight board decision (12/6/22)

2022-01 PAO (Removal of COVID-19 Misinformation)

 

All Cases: 2020-Present

2020-001-FB-UA (Malaysian Public Figure Case)

  • This case is no longer available to be reviewed by the board. It dealt with a user comment on a post and was mooted after a user deleted the original post to which the comment replied. The case concerned statements made by a former Malaysian Prime Minister about violence against French people. The case was appealed by a user after Facebook removed the content for violation of the platform’s Hate Speech policy.
  • Oversight Board description (12/1/20)
  • Facebook statement (12/1/20)

2020-002-FB-UA (Myanmar Hate Speech Case)

2020-003-FB-UA (Armenians in Azerbaijan Case)

2020-004-IG-UA (Breast Cancer Symptoms & Nudity Case)

2020-005-FB-UA (Nazi Quote Case)

2020-006-FB-FBR (Hydroxychloroquine, azithromycin and COVID-19 case)

  • This case concerns a video and accompanying text posted within a Facebook group that were related to COVID-19 and the French agency responsible for regulating health products. It was appealed by a user after Facebook removed the content for violating the platform’s Violence and Incitement Policy. After the user appealed the removal and prior to FOB ruling, Facebook identified it as an enforcement error and restored the content.
  • Oversight Board description (12/1/20)
  • Facebook statement (12/1/20)
  • Oversight Board decision (1/28/21)
  • Public comments synopsis (1/28/21)
  • Facebook response to recommendations (2/25/21)
    • "Committed to action" on 6/7 recommendations, "no further action" on 1/6 recommendations

2020-007-FB-FBR (Veiled Threats Based on Religious Beliefs Case)

2021-001-FB-FBR (Trump Suspension Case)

2021-002-FB-UA (Zwarte Piet Case)

2021-003-FB-UA (Modi & Indian Sikhs Case)

  • This case concerns a Punjabi-language video and accompanying text claiming that a Hindu nationalist organization and Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi are threatening to massacre Sikhs. It was appealed by a user after Facebook removed the content for violating its policy on Dangerous Individuals and Organizations.  After the user appealed the removal and prior to FOB ruling, Facebook identified it as an enforcement error and restored the content.
  • Oversight Board description (2/9/21)
  • Facebook statement (2/9/21)
  • Oversight Board decision (4/29/21)
  • Public comments synopsis (4/29/21)
  • Facebook response to decision (5/27/21)
    • "Committed to action" on 2/3 recommendations, "assessing feasibility" on 1/3 recommendations

2021-004-FB-UA (Navalny Protests Case)

  • This case concerns an exchange of comments between two users regarding one user's first-hand experience at the January 2021 protests in Russia over opposition leader Alexei Navalny's jailing. User A called User B a "common cowardly bot" because User B criticized the protesters, leading User B to report the comment. It was appealed by User A after Facebook removed the comment for violating its policy on Bullying and Harassment.
  • Oversight Board description (3/2/21)
  • Facebook statement (3/2/21)
  • Oversight Board decision (5/26/21)
  • Public comments synopsis (5/26/21)
  • Facebook response to recommendations (6/25/21)
    • Committed to "implementing fully" 1/6 recommendations, "implementing in part" 2/3 recommendations, "assessing feasibility" on 3/6 recommendations

2021-005-FB-UA (Armenian Hate Speech Case)

  • This case concerns an English-language "two buttons" meme posted by a United States user that depicted a Turkish flag "choosing" between two buttons that were labeled "The Armenian Genocide is a lie" and "The Armenians were terrorists who deserved it." It was appealed by the user after Facebook removed the content, initially for violating its Cruel and Insensitive Community Standard; Facebook subsequently reclassified the removal to fall under its Hate Speech policy. 
  • Oversight Board description (3/2/21)
  • Facebook statement (3/2/21)
  • Oversight Board decision (5/20/21)
  • Public comments synopsis (5/20/21)
  • Facebook response to recommendations (6/17/21)
    • Committed to "implementing fully" 1/5 recommendations, "assessing feasibility" on 4/5 recommendations

2021-006-IG-UA (PKK Founder Abdullah Ӧcalan Case)

  • This case concerns a picture posted to Instagram of Abdullah Ӧcalan, a founding member of the Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK), with accompanying text urging users to discuss ending Ӧcalan's isolation in prison. It was appealed by the user after Facebook removed the post for violating Instagram's Community Guidelines on Dangerous Individuals and Organizations.
  • Oversight Board description (4/20/21)
  • Facebook statement (4/20/21)
  • Oversight Board decision (7/8/21)
  • Public comments synopsis (7/8/21)
  • Facebook response to recommendations (8/6/21)
    • Committed to "implementing fully" 6/12 recommendations, "implementing in part" 2/12 recommendations, "assessing feasibility" on 1/12 recommendations, "no further action" on 1/12 recommendations; 2/12 recommendations deemed "work that Facebook already does"

2021-007-FB-UA (Situation in Myanmar & Profanity Case)

 

2021-008-FB-FBR (Brazilian Authority on COVID Lockdown Case)

  • This case concerns a written notice posted to Facebook by a Brazilian state-level medical authority claiming that lockdowns are ineffective and against the population's rights. It was not reported, nor removed from the platform, but Facebook referred the case to the board, stating that the content does not directly violate Facebook's policies, but could be removed under the Misinformation and Harm policy within Facebook's Violence and Incitement Community Standard.
  • Oversight Board description (6/2/21)
  • Facebook statement (6/2/21)
  • Oversight Board decision (8/19/21)
  • Public comments synopsis (8/19/21)
  • Facebook response to recommendations (9/17/21)
    • Committed to "fully implementing" 1/3 recommendations; 2/3 recommendations deemed "work that Facebook already does"
 

2021-009-FB-UA (Al Jazeera Post on Israel & Palestine Case)

  • This case concerns a post from a verified Al Jazeera news page about escalating violence in Israel and Palestine, consisting of a photo of individuals wearing Hamas military insignia with text in Arabic that stated, "'He Who Warns is Excused.' Al-Qassam Brigades military spokesman threatens the occupation forces if they do not withdraw from Al-Aqsa Mosque." It was appealed by the user after Facebook initially removed the post for violating its Dangerous Individuals and Organizations Community Standard; after the Board asked Facebook to confirm the eligibility of this post for review, Facebook identified the removal as an enforcement error and restored the content.
  • Oversight Board description (6/30/21)
  • Facebook statement (6/30/21)
  • Oversight Board decision (9/14/21)
  • Public comments synopsis (9/14/21)
  • Facebook response to recommendations (10/14/21)
    • Committed to "fully implementing" 1/4 recommendations, "implementing in part" 1/4 recommendations, "assessing feasibility" on 2/4 recommendations

2021-010-FB-UA (Protests in Colombia Case)

2021-011-FB-UA (Slurs to Discuss Situation in South Africa Case)

2021-012-FB-UA (Indigenous Art and Kamloops School Case)

  • This case concerns a picture posted to Facebook of Indigenous artwork, with accompanying text referencing the Kamloops story about unmarked graves at a former residential school for First Nations children in Canada.  It was appealed by the user after Facebook removed the post for violating its Hate Speech policy; after the Board selected the case, Facebook identified the removal as an enforcement error and restored the content.
  • Oversight Board description (9/16/21)
  • Facebook statement (9/16/21)
  • Oversight Board decision (12/9/21)
  • Public comments synopsis (12/9/21)
  • Meta response to recommendations (1/7/22)
    • Committed to "implementing fully" 1/3 recommendations, "assessing feasibility" on 1/3 recommendations, 1/3 recommendations deemed "work Meta already does"

2021-013-IG-UA (Ayahuasca Case)

  • This case concerns a picture posted to Instagram of a jarred liquid with accompanying text describing the substance as ayahuasca and stating that it is a "remedy" that "can help you." It was appealed by the user after Facebook removed the content for violating Instagram's Community Guidelines on Regulated Goods.
  • Oversight Board description (9/16/21)
  • Facebook statement (9/16/21)
  • Oversight Board decision (12/9/21)
  • Public comments synopsis (12/9/21)
  • Meta response to recommendations (1/7/22)
    • Committed to "implementing fully" 1/3 recommendations, "implementing in part" 1/3 recommendations, "assessing feasibility" on 1/3 recommendations

2021-014-FB-UA (Violence in Tigray Case)

  • This case concerns text posted to Facebook in July 2021 alleging that the Tigray People's Liberation Front killed and raped women and children. It was appealed by the user after Facebook removed the post for violating its Hate Speech Community Standard; after the Board selected the case, Facebook identified the removal as an enforcement error and restored the content.
  • Oversight Board description (9/16/21)
  • Facebook statement (9/16/21)
  • Oversight Board decision (12/14/21)
  • Public comments synopsis (12/14/21)
  • Meta response to recommendations (1/13/22)
    • Committed to "implementing in part" 1/3 recommendations, "assessing feasibility on 1/3 recommendations," "no further action" on 1/3 recommendations

2021-015-FB-UA (Advice on Pharmaceutical Drugs Case)

  • This case concerns text posted to a private Facebook group for adults with ADHD in which a user requested advice for speaking to a doctor about specific prescription drugs. It was appealed by the user after Facebook removed the post for violating its Regulated Goods Community Standard; after the Board selected the case, Facebook identified the removal as an enforcement error and restored the content.
  • Oversight Board description (11/2/21)
  • Facebook statement (11/2/21)
  • Oversight Board decision (2/1/22)
  • Public comments synopsis (2/1/22)
  • Meta response to recommendations (4/1/22)
    • Committed to "implementing fully" 1/3 recommendations; "implementing in part" 1/3 recommendations; "assessing feasibility" for 1/3 recommendations

2021-016-FB-FBR (Journalism on Sexual Violence Case)

  • This case concerns text posted to Facebook by a Swedish journalist describing sexual violence against minors. The post was originally reported in 2019, at which point Facebook found the content to be non-violating. Facebook later removed the post for violating its Child Sexual Exploitation, Abuse and Nudity Community Standard after the content was flagged again in 2021, at which point Facebook referred the case to the board.
  • Oversight Board description (11/2/21)
  • Facebook statement (11/2/21)
  • Oversight Board decision (2/1/22) 
  • Public comments synopsis (2/1/22)
  • Meta response to recommendations (4/1/22)
    • Committed to "implementing fully" 2/2 recommendations

2021-017-FB-UA (Taliban and Afghanistan Case)

  • This case concerns text posted to Facebook in August 2021 in support of the Taliban's takeover of Afghanistan. It was appealed by the user after Facebook removed the post for violating its Dangerous Individuals and Organizations Community Standard; after the Board selected the case, Facebook identified the removal as an enforcement error and restored the content.
  • Oversight Board description (11/2/21)
  • Facebook statement (11/2/21)
  • Withdrawn in Dec. 2021: "Due to user action, this case is no longer available for review by the Board. The user who appealed the case to the Board has deleted their post which has now been removed from the platform."

2022-001-FB-UA (Knin Cartoon Case)

  • This case concerns an edited cartoon video posted to Facebook depicting a city, labeled as the Croation city of Knin, overrun by rats. The content was reported more than 390 times; after Meta determined the content was not in violation of its Community Standards, a user who had reported the content appealed the decision to leave it up. After the Board selected the case, Meta identified the decision to keep the content up as an enforcement error and removed it as a violation of the Hate Speech policy.
  • Oversight Board description (3/15/22)
  • Meta statement (3/15/22)
  • Oversight Board decision (6/17/22)
  • Public comments synopsis (6/17/22)
  • Meta response to recommendations (8/16/22)
    • Committed to "implementing fully" 1/2 recommendations and "implementing in part" 1/2 recommendations.

2022-002-FB-MR (Sudan Graphic Video Case)

  • This case concerns a graphic video depicting a civilian victim of violence in Sudan following a military coup in the country on Oct. 25, 20211. It was referred by Meta after Meta first took down the post for violating the Violent and Graphic Content Community Standard, and then restored it under the newsworthiness allowance.
  • Oversight Board description (3/15/22)
  • Meta statement (3/15/22)
  • Oversight Board decision (6/13/22)
  • Public comments synopsis (6/13/22)
  • Meta response to recommendations (8/12/22)
    • Committed to "implementing full 1/4 recommendations" and "assessing feasibility" for 3/4 recommendations.

2022-003-IG-UA (Reclaiming Arabic Words Case)

  • This case concerns a series of photos posted to Instagram showing different words that can be used in derogatory ways towards men with "effeminate mannerisms" in the Arabic world by an account that identifies itself as a space for discussing queer narratives in the Arabic culture. It was appealed by the user after Meta removed the content for violating its Hate Speech Community Standard; after a total of six reviews by human content moderators, Meta determined that the post did not actually violate the Hate Speech policy.
  • Oversight Board description (3/15/22)
  • Meta statement (3/15/22)
  • Oversight Board decision (6/13/22)
  • Public comments synopsis (6/13/22)
  • Meta response to recommendations  (8/16/2022)
    • Committed to "implementing fully" 3/4 recommendations; "no further action" on 1/4 recommendations.

2022-004-FB-UA (Colombian Police Cartoon Case)

  • This case concerns a comment with a cartoon posted to Facebook depicting violence by the National Police of Colombia. It was appealed by the user after Meta removed the content, initially for violating its policy on Dangerous Individuals and Organizations, then later, for violating its policy on Violence and Incitement. After the Board selected the case, Meta identified the removal as an enforcement error and restored the content.
  • Oversight Board description (5/11/22)
  • Meta statement (5/11/22)
  • Oversight Board decision (9/14/22)
  • Public comments synopsis (9/14/22)

2022-005-FB-UA (Mention of the Taliban in News Case)

  • This case concerns a Facebook post by an Indian news organization about a Taliban announcement on the education of women. It was appealed by the user after Meta removed the content for violating its Dangerous Individuals and Organizations community standard; after the Board selected the case, Meta identified the removal as an enforcement error and restored the content.
  • Oversight Board description (5/11/22)
  • Meta statement (5/11/22)
  • Oversight Board decision (9/14/22)
  • Public comments synopsis (9/14/22)
  • Meta response to recommendations (11/14/22)
    • Committed to "implementing fully" 2/7 recommendations; "assessing feasibility" on 5/7 recommendations.

2022-006-FB-MR (Tigray Communication Affairs Bureau Case)

  • This case concerns content posted to Facebook by the Tigray Communication Affairs Bureau criticizing the leadership of Ethiopian Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed, which was reported by 10 users. It was referred by Meta after the post was removed for violating its Violence and Incitement policy, stating that the decision was difficult because it involves removing "official government speech that could be considered newsworthy."
  • Oversight Board description (5/11/22)
  • Meta statement (5/11/22)
  • Oversight Board decision (10/4/22)
  • Public comments synopsis (10/4/22)

2022-007-IG-MR (U.K. Drill Music Case)

  • This case concerns a 21-second clip from a music video from a British rapper that was posted to an Instagram account publicizing British music. It was referred by Meta after the post was removed for violating its Violence and Incitement policy, a determination made after U.K. law enforcement requested that the company remove the content due to the belief that it could stoke imminent violence. 
  • Oversight Board description (7/26/22)
  • Meta statement (7/26/22)
  • Oversight Board decision (11/22/22)
  • Public comments synopsis (11/22/22)

2022-008-FB-UA (Russian Poem Case)

  • This case concerns a Facebook post by a Latvian user depicting an individual who was killed in the Ukrainian city of Bucha with text containing an excerpt from a Russian poem and drawing a connection between the conduct of Soviet soldiers in WWII and the conduct of Ukrainian soldiers following Russia's invasion. It was appealed by the user after Meta removed the content for violating its Hate Speech Community Standard; as a result of the board's selection of the case, Meta determined that the removal was an enforcement error and reinstated it.
  • Oversight Board description (7/26/22)
  • Meta statement (7/26/22)
  • Oversight Board decision (11/16/22)
  • Public comments synopsis (11/16/22)

2022-009-IG-UA (Gender Identity and Nudity Case, Individual)

2022-010-IG-UA (Gender Identity and Nudity Case, Couple)

  • These cases concern two separate Instagram posts by the same account featuring two individuals who identify as transgender and non-binary, nude from the waist up with their nipples covered, with text discussing plans to document the transition surgery process. It was appealed by the users after Meta removed both posts under the Sexual Solicitation Community Standard; as a result of the board selecting these posts, Meta identified the removals as enforcement errors and restored the posts.
  • Oversight Board description (7/26/22)
  • Meta statement--Individual (7/26/22)
  • Meta statement--Couple (7/26/22)
  • Oversight Board decision (1/17/23)
  • Public comments synopsis (1/17/23)

2022-011-IG-UA (Video after Nigeria Church Attack Case)

2022-012-IG-MR (India Sexual Harassment Video Case)

  • This case concerns a video posted to Instagram showing a woman being assaulted by a group of men with accompanying text stating that a "tribal woman" was sexually assaulted in public. Meta referred the case to the board after initially removing the content for violating the Adult Sexual Exploitation policy, then restoring the content with a warning screen following the issuance of a newsworthiness allowance. In its referral, Meta noted that it highlights the difficulty in finding "the appropriate balance between allowing content that condemns sexual exploitation and the harm in allowing visual depictions of sexual harassment to remain on [its] platforms."
  • Oversight Board description (9/15/22)
  • Meta statement (9/15/22)
  • Oversight Board decision (12/14/22)
  • Public comments synopsis (12/14/22)

2022-013-FB-UA (Iran Protest Slogan Case)

  • This case concerns an image posted to a Facebook group depicting a caricature of Iran's supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, with accompanying text that calls for death to Khamenei and the "anti-women Islamic government" in Iran. It was appealed by the user after Meta removed the content for violating the Violence and Incitement Community Standard; as a result of the board selecting this post, Meta identified the removal as an enforcement error and restored the posts.
  • Oversight Board description (10/4/22)
  • Meta statement (10/4/22)

2022-014-FB-MR (Sri Lanka Pharmaceuticals Case)

  • This case concerns text posted to the Facebook page of a medical organization in Sri Lanka which provided a link for people to donate pharmaceutical drugs and medical supplies to the country, which was reportedly experiencing a widespread shortage of medical goods at the time due to financial crisis. Meta referred the case to the board after making a temporary exception to allow the content, though it's Restricted Goods and Services policy normally prohibits content that "[a]ttempts to donate or gift pharmaceutical drugs."
  • Oversight Board description (11/10/22)
  • Meta statement (11/10/22)
  • Oversight board decision (3/9/23)
  • Public comments synopsis (3/9/23)

2023-001-FB-UA (Brazilian General's Speech Case)

  • This case concerns a video posted to Facebook two days after the inauguration of Brazil's president in which a prominent Brazilian general called for people to "besiege" the Congress as "the last alternative." It was appealed by a user who reported the post after several human reviewers found that it did not violate Meta's policies; as a result of the board selecting this case, Meta determined that its repeated decisions to leave the content on Facebook were in error and removed the content on Jan. 20, 2023.
  • Oversight board description (3/9/23)
  • Meta statement (3/9/23)

2023-002-IG-UA (Violence Against Women Testimony Case)

  •  This case concerns a video posted to Instagram in Swedish in which a woman described her experience in a violent intimate relationship. It was appealed by the user after Meta removed the content under its Hate Speech community standard; as a result of the board selecting this case, Meta determined that its decision to remove the content was in error and restored the post.
  • Oversight board description (3/9/23)
  • Meta statement (3/9/23)

2023-003-FB-MR (Cambodian Prime Minister Case)

  • This case concerns a video posted of a long speech delivered by Cambodia's prime minister, Hun Sen, including statements made by the prime minister offering some a choice between legal action or physical force. Meta referred the case to the board adter it was reported by several users and Meta allowed it to remain on the platform despite determining that it violated the platform's Violence and Incitement Community Standard under a newsworthiness allowance.
  • Oversight board description (3/16/23)
  • Meta statement (3/16/23)